The Island of Dr. Moreau ratings (Movie, 1996)

Set in the year 2010, Dr. Moreau has successfully combined human and animal DNA to make a crossbreed animal. Well, as usual, something goes wrong and David Thewlis must try to stop it before it is too late. Originally rated R, but cut by Frankenheimer to allow "a wider audience".

I Know What You Did Last Summer
Total votes: 177,401
Average rating: 5.8 Halloween H20: 20 Years Later
Total votes: 87,673
Average rating: 5.8 Urban Legend
Total votes: 77,286
Average rating: 5.6 I Still Know What You Did Last Summer
Total votes: 86,912
Average rating: 4.8 Village of the Damned
Total votes: 36,390
Average rating: 5.7 Psycho
Total votes: 52,370
Average rating: 4.6 The Relic
Total votes: 32,107
Average rating: 5.8 Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers
Total votes: 46,014
Average rating: 4.7 Disturbing Behavior
Total votes: 27,153
Average rating: 5.7 Phantoms
Total votes: 24,202
Average rating: 5.4