I Married a Witch ratings (Movie, 1942)

In 1672, two witches (Jennifer and her father Daniel) were burned by puritan Jonathan Wooley. In revenge, Jennifer cursed all future generations of the Wooley family, that the sons will always marry the wrong woman and be miserable. In the 20th century, a bolt of lightning frees Jennifer and her father from the tree that had kept their souls imprisoned. Jennifer assumes corporeal form and decides to make up-and-coming politician Wallace Wooley, then unhappily engaged, even more miserable by getting him to fall in love with her before his wedding. Wallace is a straight arrow, though, and Jennifer has to resort to a love potion. As we all know, love potions tend to backfire, with comedic results.

The Wizard of Oz
Total votes: 428,539
Average rating: 8.1 Gone with the Wind
Total votes: 334,212
Average rating: 8.2 Rebecca
Total votes: 146,686
Average rating: 8.1 Mr. Smith Goes to Washington
Total votes: 121,366
Average rating: 8.1 Arsenic and Old Lace
Total votes: 74,961
Average rating: 7.9 The Philadelphia Story
Total votes: 73,831
Average rating: 7.9 His Girl Friday
Total votes: 63,136
Average rating: 7.8 Spellbound
Total votes: 52,226
Average rating: 7.5 Brief Encounter
Total votes: 44,219
Average rating: 8.0 To Be or Not to Be
Total votes: 42,999
Average rating: 8.1