The Prestige ratings (Movie, 2006)

In the end of the nineteenth century, in London, Robert Angier, his beloved wife Julia McCullough, and Alfred Borden are friends and assistants of a magician. When Julia accidentally dies during a performance, Robert blames Alfred for her death, and they become enemies. Both become famous and rival magicians, sabotaging the performance of the other on the stage. When Alfred performs a successful trick, Robert becomes obsessed trying to disclose the secret of his competitor with tragic consequences.

Inglourious Basterds
Total votes: 1,582,705
Average rating: 8.4 No Country for Old Men
Total votes: 1,059,304
Average rating: 8.2 Gran Torino
Total votes: 814,605
Average rating: 8.1 Pan's Labyrinth
Total votes: 702,678
Average rating: 8.2 Into the Wild
Total votes: 657,839
Average rating: 8.1 There Will Be Blood
Total votes: 640,641
Average rating: 8.2 Blood Diamond
Total votes: 585,689
Average rating: 8.0 The Pursuit of Happyness
Total votes: 560,375
Average rating: 8.0 Zodiac
Total votes: 597,899
Average rating: 7.7 Troy
Total votes: 570,113
Average rating: 7.3