The Tin Star ratings (Movie, 1957)

Veteran bounty-hunter Morg Hickman rides into a town in danger. The sheriff has been killed, and young inexperienced Ben Owens named a temporary replacement until a permanent can be found. Ben wants to be that permanent replacement, so needs to impress the townspeople with his skill. When he finds that Morg was a sheriff for a long time before he became a bounty-hunter, he asks the older man to teach him. Morg thinks that being a sheriff is a foolish goal, but agrees to instruct Ben in handling people, more important to a sheriff than handling a gun.

Ben-Hur
Total votes: 253,368
Average rating: 8.1 The Bridge on the River Kwai
Total votes: 233,063
Average rating: 8.1 Paths of Glory
Total votes: 212,002
Average rating: 8.4 The Seventh Seal
Total votes: 198,225
Average rating: 8.1 On the Waterfront
Total votes: 164,654
Average rating: 8.1 Witness for the Prosecution
Total votes: 137,641
Average rating: 8.4 Spartacus
Total votes: 143,049
Average rating: 7.9 The 400 Blows
Total votes: 127,949
Average rating: 8.1 Touch of Evil
Total votes: 109,703
Average rating: 8.0 The Night of the Hunter
Total votes: 97,206
Average rating: 8.0